Professional Liability Insurance SimplifiedKeeping Your Insurance Simple & Effective
Have Questions? Need Help? Call Us! 1-877-569-4111

The Legal Elements of a Lawyers Professional Liability “Claim”

February 9, 2018


As we have covered in other posts, for insurance purposes, a “claim” is any demand for damages made against an attorney in the course of providing professional services. Not surprisingly, an actual legal claim requires a little more to be viable in court.

In general, a legal professional liability claim has three elements: 1) proof that the lawyer owed a professional duty to the complainant; proof that the lawyer—or her agent—breached that duty; and proof that the claimant suffered quantifiable monetary damage as a direct result.

Let’s look at each element in turn.

Duty to the complainant

This element has two subparts: did the lawyer owe a duty to the particular complaining party and, if so, what exactly was it?

Legal professional liability law has evolved to expand the scope of a lawyer’s professional obligations to include a range of people beyond the “client” who came into the lawyer’s office. The definition of a “client,” or someone to whom the lawyer may become duty-bound, rests in perception and implied duty: if the complainant can establish that he reasonably understood, based upon the lawyer’s actions and words and all the circumstances, that the lawyer would be looking out for his interests, that is enough. The burden is on the defendant lawyer to show that the belief wasn’t reasonable, in order to limit the reach of her legal responsibilities.

This means that you could find yourself facing potential liability toward someone you did not actually consider to be a client, including your client’s family members, other parties in a business transaction, or even sometimes opposing parties, depending upon the circumstances.

Breach Of Duty

Once a complainant establishes that a lawyer owed them a professional obligation, they must then establish the full extent of that duty, and that the attorney—or an agent—failed to fulfill some essential portion thereof. This can be tricky for the client, especially when the underlying representation required the attorney to exercise professional judgment about how to proceed in the midst of a litigation or negotiation: it may be difficult to prove that the attorney’s “failure” to call a witness was, in fact, a breach of duty, or that another strategy was recklessly negligent. Other claims are easier to prove, like when an attorney misses a deadline, or releases information to the wrong party, or overlooks an essential element of the claim she was asked to pursue.

Causation And Damages

A standard element of any negligence claim, the challenge for legal malpractice plaintiffs is often the causation part of this equation. Again, this is especially true for litigation representations; when the trial judge’s ruling may have tipped the balance for the client, it is hard to connect the client’s resulting losses directly to the lawyer’s actions or inactions. But in many representations the complainant can relatively easily draw a line from your breach of duty directly to their loss, leaving calculating your liability the only remaining dispute in the case.

Protexure Lawyers /// Professional Liability Made Easy

“I found the Protexure representatives to be extremely professional, knowledgeable, and courteous. They found similar coverage for me for a substantial amount less than I had been paying. I have been pleased with Protexure’s service and would recommend it highly.”

- David M. Lipschutz, Esquire

Receiving a quote from Protexure Lawyers is made super easy by the quick response time of their team. The renewal process is different from what I have ever seen, they offer a mostly filled out application which made the process even easier for me!

- Eric Schwab - Woodbridge, NJ

It was a pleasure working with you, - you gave me the most competitive price, quick turn around and good follow-up.

- Howard S. Kavenow

My account representative was very helpful in assisting me to complete my application. He made me feel like my questions and my business were a priority to him.

- Kim Davis

When faced with a substantial increase from our existing malpractice carrier, we received the name Protexure Lawyers from a referral. On contact, they were not only very prompt in processing our application, but also responded to several coverage questions we had. So far, the service has been excellent.

- Law Office of Shriver, O'Neill & Thompson

Mr. Dixon contacted me many months ago and I told him I renew my policy in September and that it would be helpful to contact me in July or August of this year. He did that; he was very patient with me and assisted me with the application process. He was extremely prompt in replying to my inquiries. I had been with the same company for many years so I was reluctant to leave them. He made the transition quite simple. I am fortunate that he was the salesman who contacted me.

- Robert Lewin

Thanks. You guys got my business because (a) your price was great, and (b) you were responsive and on top of things (a number of insurers surprisingly were not).

- Scott Maxwell

I first came in contact with Ryan on a cold call. Usually I am dismissive of these types of calls, but Ryan was brief and to the point - no hard sell or over promising. In the end, I received a less expensive policy than others I researched. I guess not all cold calls are a bad thing.

- Steve Hunter

Ryan offered to compare my current insurance with what he and his company could offer. I took him up on this, and gave him my pertinent information. I did my own research, and discovered that his quote was lower and the carrier had an A rating. I contacted my existing agent to see if she could match the quote. I had been her customer for a number of years and thought that was fair. She was unable to match Ryan's offer.

- Steve Hunter

I discussed some minor differences in the policies with my account representative, and throughout the process, he was easy to reach and called me back promptly. I value this a great deal. In the end, it was clear to me that I would receive a less expensive policy than I currently have, with the same coverage and excellent customer service.

- Steve Hunter

Copyright © 2019 All Rights Reserved

Have A Question?

We are here to help! Fill out the form below and we will get back to you shortly.

You have Successfully Submitted your question!